Menu
Schedule a Consultation
If you are a lawful permanent resident planning to apply for United States citizenship, you should be cognizant of the many changes affecting this area, particularly when it comes to how USCIS is evaluating Good Moral Character. If there weren’t already enough policy changes this year, the agency recently released PM-602-0201, which significantly expands how officers will evaluate good moral character in the context of child support obligations, affidavit of support obligations, public benefit history, and what USCIS is now calling intentional avoidance of self-sufficiency.
What the memo calls for is not a minor procedural change. It represents a meaningful expansion of the scrutiny applied during the naturalization process, and it has direct implications for permanent residents throughout New Jersey contemplating naturalization. We are already seeing the effects of previous shifts in interviews at the Newark, Cranbury, and Mount Laurel field offices, where officers are inquiring into areas or subjects that simply were not part of the N-400 interview process a year ago.
To naturalize as a United States citizen, an applicant must demonstrate good moral character during the statutory period, which is either the five years immediately preceding the filing of the N-400, or three years for applicants naturalizing through marriage to a U.S. citizen spouse (under Section 319 of the Immigration and Nationality Act). Good moral character is not defined by a single act or omission. It is evaluated by measuring an applicant's conduct against the standards of the average citizen in the community. But of course, this is where things can get very subjective.
Certain conduct, of course, such as murder, constitutes an absolute bar to naturalization regardless of when it occurred, and very few people would argue with that. And there is other types of conduct which constitute a conditional bar if it occurred during the statutory period. Willful failure or refusal to support dependents has traditionally been a conditional bar under 8 C.F.R. § 316.10 for many years. What PM-602-0201 does now is instruct officers to apply that standard more broadly, more proactively, and with more liberal exercise of discretion.
The requirement to support one's dependents is not new to naturalization law. What is new, though, is the operational guidance officers are receiving about how to identify and evaluate it. Under PM-602-0201, officers are explicitly authorized to find a lack of good moral character even in the absence of a court order establishing a support obligation. An applicant does not need to have been held in contempt by a family court for USCIS to consider inadequate financial support of a child or spouse as a character problem impinging on one’s fitness for citizenship.
More significantly, the memo instructs officers to treat a dependent child's reliance on means-tested public benefits, including Medicaid, SNAP, and TANF, as potential circumstantial evidence of nonsupport. This is a meaningful shift. It means that an applicant whose child has been receiving public assistance during the statutory period may face questions at the N-400 interview about why that child required government assistance and what the applicant was contributing financially. The burden will be on the applicant to provide a satisfactory explanation.
For applicants who are separated from a former spouse or who have children from a prior relationship, this section of the memo demands attention before the N-400 is filed. If there is any gap in the support record, whether due to job loss, a period of incarceration, a family dispute, or simple neglect, that history needs to be identified and addressed with counsel in advance.
The memo also extends its scrutiny to the financial commitments made during the green card process. When a U.S. citizen or permanent resident sponsors a family member for a green card, they execute a Form I-864, Affidavit of Support. That form creates a legally enforceable obligation to support the sponsored immigrant at 125 percent of the federal poverty guidelines. The obligation runs until the sponsored immigrant naturalizes, earns forty qualifying quarters of Social Security work credits, departs the United States, or dies.
PM-602-0201 instructs officers to examine whether applicants who signed I-864 forms has met those obligations. If a sponsored immigrant received means-tested public benefits while the I-864 was still enforceable, and if the sponsor has failed to meet the support obligation, that failure may now militate against the sponsor's good moral character. The memo makes clear that a sponsored immigrant's mere receipt of benefits is not automatic proof of a breach, but it does allow inquiry in a way that officers were not previously directed to pursue.
Many of our clients in Middlesex and Union counties sponsored parents or siblings for green cards who subsequently needed NJ FamilyCare or other public assistance. This is precisely the type of scenario this memo addresses. If you sponsored a family member who received public benefits while your I-864 obligation was still active, that history is also something worth reviewing with counsel prior to filing or before an interview.
PM-602-0201 draws a clear distinction between lawful receipt of public benefits and conduct that raises a character concern. Technically, lawful receipt alone of benefits by an applicant who was eligible and applied truthfully does not present a bar to naturalization and cannot by itself support an adverse finding. That being said, the memo targets any fraud or misrepresentation made in connection with receiving benefits. This includes underreporting income on a benefit application, misstating household composition, failing to report changes in financial circumstances, and failing to disclose a sponsor's income or assets when required. Any of these could also potentially constitute a crime involving moral turpitude depending on the circumstances, which carries more serious consequences for naturalization than the conditional bar for nonsupport.
The memo also introduces what it calls intentional avoidance of self-sufficiency. This is the most novel element of the guidance. It addresses situations where an applicant takes deliberate steps, such as reducing work hours or declining available employment, intentionally to remain under income thresholds and thereby qualify for means-tested public benefits. The memo does recognize that people reduce hours for many legitimate reasons, including medical conditions, disabilities, and caregiving obligations, and those situations are weighed differently. But where an officer concludes that the reduction was a deliberate financial strategy rather than a necessity, it may be held against the applicant's character under a totality-of-circumstances review.
New Jersey has one of the largest and most diverse permanent resident populations in the country, and many of the situations PM-602-0201 addresses are commonplace here. Families who received NJ FamilyCare or SNAP during the pandemic or during periods of unemployment, applicants who have children from prior relationships, permanent residents who sponsored family members who subsequently needed public assistance are examples of populations that may be subject to heightened scrutiny as a result of these changes.
This does not mean applicants in these situations cannot naturalize. But it does mean that these types of applicants would do well to prepare and be ready to address these issues at the interview.
On a related note, one issue that has come up with increasing frequency during naturalization interviews is the treatment of federal tax filing extensions. USCIS has been denying or delaying naturalization applications where applicants filed for extensions under Form 4868, apparently on the basis that failure to file on time constitutes a lack of moral character—even when the returns were filed in compliance with the extended deadline. This is a striking and disturbing change in posture considering how USCIS previously treated these types of situations and is emblematic of how rigorous and strict agency standards have become.
Lee & Garasia, LLC has been representing clients in naturalization matters throughout New Jersey for close to thirty years. Whether it is a straightforward application or a case involving complex good moral character issues, prior criminal history, periods of public benefit receipt, support disputes, or gaps in the statutory period record, we have covered the gamut.
If you need help in either applying or attending the interview, our office is ready to help you.